Top Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a Medicare Plan
Kelli Schmatz • September 3, 2025

September 3, 2025

Choosing a Medicare plan is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when it comes to protecting your health and finances. With so many options, rules, and potential costs, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. But the truth is, selecting the wrong plan—or overlooking certain details—can lead to higher out-of-pocket expenses, limited access to doctors, or gaps in the care you need.


Making an informed choice about your Medicare coverage requires a careful understanding of common mistakes and how to avoid them. By learning from the challenges others have faced, you can confidently choose a plan that supports your health and lifestyle. According to Forbes, as of April 2024, approximately 67.3 million U.S. adults are enrolled in Medicare coverage, which makes choosing wisely more important than ever.


Below, we’ll cover the top mistakes people make when selecting Medicare plans and how you can sidestep them to ensure your needs are met.


Not Comparing All of Your Options


One of the biggest mistakes people make is assuming that all Medicare plans are the same or that their first choice is automatically the best one. Medicare offers multiple options, including Original Medicare (Parts A and B), Medicare Advantage (Part C), and standalone prescription drug coverage (Part D). In addition, supplemental Medigap policies can help cover costs that Original Medicare does not.


Each of these plans comes with its own set of rules, costs, and benefits. Failing to compare them side by side could mean missing out on better coverage or lower premiums. For example, Medicare Advantage plans often include additional benefits like vision and dental, but they may also have limited provider networks. On the other hand, Original Medicare offers flexibility in choosing doctors but doesn’t cap out-of-pocket costs.


Taking the time to evaluate all your options ensures you’re not stuck with a plan that doesn’t suit your lifestyle or financial situation.


Ignoring Prescription Drug Coverage


Prescription drug costs can add up quickly, and many people make the mistake of assuming they won’t need Part D coverage if they don’t currently take medication. Unfortunately, this can lead to costly penalties and coverage gaps later on. If you decide not to enroll in Part D when you’re first eligible and then need it later, you’ll face a permanent late enrollment penalty that increases the longer you wait.


Even if you’re in good health now, it’s wise to plan for the future. Medications are often a necessary part of aging, and having drug coverage in place can protect you from high expenses down the road. Reviewing different Part D plans and ensuring your medications are covered can prevent frustrating surprises and ensure your healthcare budget stays manageable.


Overlooking Provider Networks


Another common mistake is forgetting to check whether your preferred doctors and specialists are included in a plan’s network. This is especially true for those considering Medicare Advantage plans, which typically operate within a set group of providers. If you enroll in a plan without confirming that your physicians participate, you may end up paying significantly more out-of-pocket or needing to switch doctors altogether.


Always double-check provider directories before enrolling. It’s also a good idea to confirm directly with your doctor’s office, as networks can change from year to year. By making sure your providers are included, you’ll maintain continuity of care and avoid unexpected bills.


Misunderstanding Out-of-Pocket Costs


Premiums are only one piece of the puzzle when it comes to Medicare coverage. Many people focus solely on the monthly premium price and fail to account for other costs like deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. These expenses can add up quickly, especially if you have ongoing medical needs or require hospital stays.


For instance, a plan with a low premium might seem attractive but could come with high out-of-pocket expenses when you actually need care. On the other hand, a higher premium plan may offer better cost-sharing protections and lower annual expenses overall. The key is to look at the total cost of coverage, not just the monthly price tag.


Failing to Consider Future Needs


It’s natural to base decisions on your current health, but overlooking potential future needs is a mistake. Healthcare demands typically increase with age, and the plan you choose today should be flexible enough to handle changes down the road.


Think about whether you may need specialized care, access to certain medications, or even long-term treatments in the future. Choosing a plan that offers comprehensive coverage now can save you from needing to switch later or facing limited benefits when your needs grow. Planning ensures your Medicare coverage remains reliable no matter what comes your way.


Skipping Annual Reviews


Many people assume that once they pick a Medicare plan, they’re set for life. In reality, plans can change from year to year. Premiums, provider networks, drug formularies, and benefits often shift, meaning a plan that worked well last year might not be the best fit now.


The Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), which runs from October 15th to December 7th each year, gives you the chance to review your plan and make changes if necessary. Failing to take advantage of this opportunity could leave you stuck with higher costs or reduced benefits. By reviewing your plan annually, you can adapt to changes and ensure your coverage remains the best choice.


Overestimating What Original Medicare Covers


Another mistake is assuming that Original Medicare covers everything. While it provides hospital and medical insurance, it doesn’t cover all services. For example, dental care, vision exams, hearing aids, and most long-term care services are not included. This can come as a surprise to many enrollees, especially those who didn’t plan for additional expenses.


To avoid unexpected costs, consider whether a Medicare Advantage plan or a supplemental Medigap policy would better suit your needs. These options can help fill the gaps left by Original Medicare and give you more comprehensive coverage.


Forgetting About Travel Coverage


If you plan to travel frequently, especially outside of the United States, forgetting to check your Medicare plan’s travel coverage can be a costly mistake. Original Medicare generally does not cover healthcare outside the country, and many Advantage plans have limited networks that may not extend beyond your local area.


If travel is part of your lifestyle, look for supplemental policies that include foreign travel emergency benefits or consider plans that provide broader access to care. Ensuring you’re protected while traveling can save you significant stress and expense in the event of a medical emergency away from home.


Selecting a Medicare plan doesn’t have to be overwhelming, but avoiding the most common mistakes is key to getting the right coverage. By comparing options, reviewing provider networks, considering drug coverage, and planning for both current and future needs, you’ll set yourself up for success. Remember to review your plan each year and make adjustments as your health and lifestyle change.


Medicare is a critical part of protecting your health and financial stability. With so many people relying on it, taking the time to choose wisely ensures you’ll enjoy peace of mind and reliable access to care for years to come.


If you’re ready to explore your options and avoid costly mistakes, Teton Medicare is here to help. Our knowledgeable team can walk you through the process, answer your questions, and match you with the plan that fits your unique needs. Contact us today to get started and secure the Medicare coverage you deserve.

< Older Post Newer Post >
medicare

Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: Which Is Right for You?

December 23, 2025
For some beneficiaries, Original Medicare’s consistent premiums may be preferable, offering stability despite potential cost uncertainties in other coverage.
insurance guidance

How to Compare Medicare Plans for Best Coverage

December 23, 2025
Discover how to compare Medicare plans effectively with professional insurance guidance that helps you balance coverage, costs, and care needs.
medicare supplement

The Most Common Mistakes to Avoid With Medicare Enrollment

November 26, 2025
Medicare supplement enrollment can be a daunting process filled with potential pitfalls. This article will explore the most common mistakes people make when enrolling in Medicare and provide guidance on how to avoid them. Understanding these errors is crucial for ensuring that your healthcare coverage meets your needs and avoids unnecessary costs. As you prepare to enroll, being informed will help you navigate the intricacies of the process with confidence. By addressing each section outlined, you'll be well-equipped to make the best decisions for your health and financial well-being. Misunderstanding Enrollment Periods The Initial Enrollment Period (IEP) is a seven-month period that begins three months before you turn 65, includes the month of your birthday, and ends three months after. Missing this period could mean delayed coverage and potential penalties. Many people don't realize the importance of enrolling during this time frame, assuming they can sign up at any time without consequences. It's vital to mark your calendar and plan to take full advantage of the IEP. Waiting could lead to gaps in coverage, which might be costly if unexpected medical needs arise. If you miss your IEP, the General Enrollment Period (GEP) offers another opportunity to sign up for Medicare. However, this period runs from January 1 to March 31 each year, and coverage won't begin until July 1. By missing the initial opportunity, you could face several months without coverage. This not only increases the risk of a penalty but also leaves you vulnerable to uncovered healthcare expenses. Therefore, it's crucial to understand and keep track of these dates to optimize your Medicare benefits. The Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) is the time to make changes to your current Medicare plan, occurring each year from October 15 to December 7. While some might think their current plan will suffice, healthcare needs and plan details can change annually. Engaging in this period allows you to adjust your plan according to your healthcare needs for the upcoming year. Failing to act during this period can lead to maintaining an inadequate plan, potentially resulting in higher out-of-pocket costs. Staying informed about your current plan and alternatives is essential during AEP to ensure optimal coverage. Not Considering All Coverage Options Medicare Advantage Plans, also known as Part C, are an alternative to Original Medicare. They often offer bundled options including Part A, Part B, and sometimes Part D for prescription drugs. Many beneficiaries don't consider these plans due to a lack of understanding of their benefits. Opting for Medicare Advantage might provide more comprehensive services, like dental and vision care. By evaluating these plans, you can potentially enhance your healthcare coverage and minimize out-of-pocket costs. Medigap, or Medicare Supplement Insurance, helps cover costs not included in Original Medicare, like copayments and deductibles. Individuals often ignore these policies, thinking their basic Medicare plan is adequate. However, Medigap can provide financial peace, especially for those requiring frequent medical services. It's essential to assess your healthcare needs to determine if a Medigap policy is right for you. Ignoring this option can lead to unexpected expenses that could have been prevented with supplemental insurance. Part D covers prescription drugs, yet some individuals underestimate its value or postpone enrollment. Without Part D, you might face high out-of-pocket costs for medications. Even if you currently don't require prescriptions, needs can change, making prescription coverage crucial. Additionally, delaying Part D enrollment could result in penalties. It's wise to not only enroll in a Part D plan but also review and choose the one that best matches your medication needs. Part C, or Medicare Advantage, is an often-overlooked option that combines Parts A and B, and often Part D as well. Many beneficiaries don't fully understand how Part C works and miss out on its potential benefits. Unlike Original Medicare, Part C plans are offered through private companies, but they must follow rules set by Medicare. This plan's comprehensive coverage can be beneficial for those looking to consolidate their healthcare plans. Understanding Part C's benefits is crucial for making an informed decision about your healthcare options. Medicare supplement insurance offers a variety of benefits that are frequently overlooked. From wellness visits to screenings, these benefits can significantly support your health management. Many assume that all necessary care is automatically covered, leading to missed opportunities for preventive health measures. Staying informed about these available services ensures you're fully utilizing what Medicare offers. It's important to regularly review what's included in your plan to avoid missing out on valuable health benefits. Underestimating Healthcare Needs Many individuals fail to thoroughly assess their current health conditions when enrolling in Medicare. This oversight can lead to inadequate coverage if one's health requires more attention than anticipated. An accurate understanding of your health status can guide you to choose the right Medicare plan. Without this assessment, you risk selecting a plan that doesn't adequately cover specialist visits or necessary treatments. Regularly evaluating your health ensures that your plan aligns with your healthcare needs. Healthcare needs can evolve, making it essential to anticipate future changes when choosing a Medicare plan. Many beneficiaries focus on their immediate needs, neglecting potential future conditions. This can result in a plan that might not support long-term health changes. Recognizing the importance of future planning allows you to select a plan that adapts to your healthcare requirements. Considering potential changes ensures sustained coverage beyond your current expectations. While primary care is essential, many fail to account for specialist care when enrolling in Medicare. Certain health conditions require specialist attention, necessitating a plan that accommodates such visits. Overlooking this can result in inconveniently high out-of-pocket specialist fees. According to Medicare.gov, you can use any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare, anywhere in the United States, yet this flexibility is only beneficial if adequately planned for. Carefully estimating specialist care needs helps ensure that your coverage aligns with your medical necessities. Financial Planning Errors Proper financial planning is essential for Medicare enrollment, yet many underestimate the potential out-of-pocket costs they might face. This could include unexpected expenses like copayments, deductibles, and hospital admission fees. Without a clear understanding of these potential costs, budgeting for healthcare can become challenging. Thoroughly reviewing plan details and considering all possible expenses ensures that you select a plan within your financial means. Planning ahead allows you to prevent unexpected financial burdens due to unaccounted costs. Premium costs are recurring and can add up over time, affecting financial stability for Medicare beneficiaries. Some might focus on immediate low premiums, ignoring long-term affordability and benefits. This could lead to regrettable financial commitments or a lack of necessary coverage when needed most. Balancing premiums versus the benefits provided is essential for achieving optimal coverage without financial strain. Ensuring that premium expenses fit into your monthly budget is key to maintaining long-term financial health. Inadequate Research and Information Gathering Information regarding Medicare is subject to change, making reliance on outdated data potentially costly. Many make decisions based on historical information without understanding newer options or changes. It's critical to access the most current Medicare guidelines to ensure informed enrollment decisions. Checking reliable and up-to-date sources ensures that choices are relevant to the present healthcare environment. Continually updating your knowledge about Medicare will help optimize coverage decisions. Medicare plans can change yearly, affecting coverage, networks, and costs. Many individuals overlook these updates, sticking with a plan that might no longer meet their needs. Understanding annual changes is essential for maintaining suitable and adequate healthcare coverage. Regularly reviewing plan amendments helps you stay informed of any modifications that could impact your current and future medical care. Being proactive about studying your plan's annual changes will help maintain optimal healthcare alignment. Avoiding these common Medicare enrollment mistakes requires careful planning, attention to detail, and a thorough understanding of available options and timing. By approaching the enrollment process with the proper knowledge and preparation, you can secure the healthcare coverage that best suits your needs. Navigating through Medicare confidently is a testament to informed, strategic planning, helping to ensure seamless and effective healthcare coverage. Through diligent research and personalized decision-making, you can optimize your Medicare experience for optimal health and financial stability. In the journey of Medicare enrollment, knowledge truly proves to be a vital resource for success. For more information about the services that we offer, reach out to our incredible team at Teton Medicare today!
Show More →